Mary Macaluso

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

About Mary Macaluso

Specialties: Associate Broker, Certified Buyer Broker, Listing Agent, Buyer's Agent, Notary, Property Management, 55+ Community

With over 20 years working with buyers, sellers and renters, nothing is more gratifying to Mary than seeing clients find that special place called home, except perhaps the integral, important role she plays as the real estate professional who makes it all happen. Mary offers each and every client the same level of exceptional service and consistent, transparent communication. It’s what has helped her build strong and lasting relationships with so many clients in the Long Island residential market.

Understanding the many choices with which a buyer or seller is faced, Mary hones in on the best options for each individual, then streamlines the action plan once the right scenario comes along. Her in-depth knowledge as a long-time local resident here lend to Mary’s expert ability to negotiate the best price for you in today's highly competitive market. Becoming an associate real estate broker as well as a certified buyer broker has provided her with the advanced knowledge required to sell homes faster and to represent sellers and buyers better in one of their most important life decisions. At Compass, Mary has the essential tools and technology along with access to a greater number of new homes on the market. She works hard to ensure you receive dependable, trustworthy service. She wants you to feel like family!

Driven by a genuine desire to help others, Mary has hand-picked a team of professional agents to provide her clients with constant availability and personal attention. The Macaluso team is client focused, always listening closely and taking the time necessary to understand client goals. The team has extensive market knowledge and expertise to see your purchase or sale through to a successful close.

Before becoming a Realtor®, Mary worked in the title industry from 1989-2001. The title industry gave her a strong understanding of the behind-the-scenes of the mortgage and real estate business and made it a seamless transition for her to become a Realtor®. She has been a licensed associate broker since 2001.

Born and raised in upstate New York, Mary has called Bethpage home since 1981, Mary and her husband Roy, they have three grown children, Sara, John, and Victoria, and three grandsons. Mary is also active in local community events and is currently serving on the Board of Directors of the Bethpage Public Library since 2015.

Mary looks forward to sharing her experience with you throughout the selling and or buying process.

Testimonials

Mary Macaluso the Real Estate agent is excellent at what she does, she is the consummate professional. Mary the person is even better! That is why you need to choose her to guide you through the buying or selling process. She brings a group of individual’s who come together to form an amazing team to work on your behalf. They outwork everyone else. Why? Simple, they enjoy what they do and it shows in the product that they put out. We were lucky to have chosen Mary, John M., Lainie G., and the entire Macaluso team to sell our house. Her team's price strategy and showings all produced a home, which sold in less than 48 hours. If you want someone who cares about just making a sale...choose someone else. If you want someone who cares about your family, your home, and her community...well then you don’t have to search any further! - Rob R

Mary is amazing!! We were first time buyers and she was with us every step of the way. Highly recommend her & her team. We first took notice of Mary at an open house. After working with a previous agent and going to several open houses, Mary's professionalism & knowledge really amazed us. We quickly reached out to her to ask her to be our agent! Took us almost a year to find a home with how competitive the market was last year, but she & Lainie was with us every step of the way. She was extremely knowledgeable on what to look out for as 1st time home buyers. I couldn’t recommend her enough for anyone looking to buy a home! - Denise M

Professional demeanor available pleasure to work with. Worked with us to coordinate time frame for sale. Knowledgeable of respective area in which home was listed. -Ghaws

Mary is very knowledgeable, professional and personable. I enjoyed working with her and Gina and the rest of her team! They sold my house for a great price and found me the perfect house. I would use them again in a heartbeat and highly recommend them! - Jbones75

Mary was able to provide professional and extensive knowledge of the market that helped us secure our first home with all our needs. Throughout our open houses, and appointments, every other real estate agent made comments about Mary’s great work ethic and performance. She is well respected by all other agents and firms, proving she can go the extra step to get a deal DONE. Mary was able to introduce us to Home inspectors, attorneys, handymen, etc. that made every step of the usual gruesome home purchasing process easier. I highly recommend reaching out to Mary for your next home purchase or sale. I would personally never let friends or family go to anyone else but Mary.

When it came time to sell my mother’s home, Mary Macaluso was the first person that came to mind. From the moment the house went on the market, Mary and her team went to work. Even when Mary was in Italy, she kept in contact. Amazing! In two short months the house was sold and we closed. I highly recommend Mary if you are selling or purchasing a home.-Kathrynwill20

Highly likely to recommend

2024-03-10 - sydneykerins1

Helped me buy and sell homes

Honestly, I would give Mary ten stars in all of these categories if I could. We count ourselves incredibly lucky that we got to work with her on buying and selling. She is vastly knowledgeable, we encountered some hiccups with selling our home and Mary was ready to solve any and every issue along the way all the while keeping us calm throughout the process. Mary guided us through both the buying and selling sides with ease, she was able to answer any question we had and she has the experience to back it up. On top of all of this, she has great connections within the industry due to her kindness and professionalism. She was able to recommend us various service providers who all did a great job and spoke very highly of her. We are so happy in our new home, but if we ever needed an agent, we would call Mary again in a heartbeat!

Highly likely to recommend

2022-02-24 - n123y

Listed and sold a home

Mary is very professional and knowledgeable. She helped me a lot all the way starting from the open house to the closing. She always responded and did what she told us she would do. She is always kept in touch whether text or phone during the whole process. Mary and the whole amazing team members, such as Gina and John, were great to work with. I greatly appreciate everything Mary and her team did. We were very pleased with the service and highly recommend them if you plan on buying or selling a home.

Highly likely to recommend

2021-10-10 - gailpatrickgray

Listed and sold a home

Mary was great from start to finish! She was always available to answer any questions. We ended up selling our house for about $50,000 more than we expected. I can’t recommend Mary and her team enough!

Highly likely to recommend

2020-09-11 - jessica rose zuniga

Helped me buy and sell homes

Having Mary as our agent was the best choice we could’ve made. She helped us sell our co-op in December and helped us buy our home during these unprecedented times in a very competitive buyers market. She did this in the most smooth way possible with unwavering support throughout the entire process. Mary is professional and knowledgeable and was able to help us navigate the homebuying process from start to finish. Thank you, Mary!

Highly likely to recommend

2020-07-21 - parveenminhas

Helped me buy home

Mary Macaluso is just the best agent. We met Mary over 10 years when we were looking for a house. We recently closed on another house and everything went very smooth and quick. Mary is very transparent, patient, gives her honest feedback and guides her clients in the right direction. She is the only name that we recommend. I just want to thank Mary for being patient with us.

Highly likely to recommend

2020-04-19 - nancy petrina

Helped me buy and sell homes

Mary Macaluso is just the best. I used her as a realtor about 5 years ago when I bought my co-op. When it came time for me and my husband to start house hunting, I knew immediately that we would go straight to Mary. Mary is extremely knowledgeable in this field. She immediately makes you feel comfortable. She also looked out for our best interest! Not only that, she has a team of great people that work with you to make the process as smooth as possible! I have sent friends to Mary and they have been happy as well. I hope I never have to move again. But if I do, I know who to call!

Highly likely to recommend

2020-03-30 - lindahoeb

Listed and sold a home

Mary sold our family home in less than 30 days. She handled every aspect of the sale with the utmost professionalism and care. She had been recommended to us, and we would highly recommend her to sell your home.

Highly likely to recommend

2020-03-27 - geandrea

Listed and sold a home

Mary was very supportive and responsive in selling our house. She is consummate professional, and knows the local real estate marketplace very well...she was a pleasure to work with..

Highly likely to recommend

2020-02-05 - ghaws

Listed and sold a home

Professional demeanor available pleasure to work with. Worked with us to coordinate time frame for sale. Knowledgeable of respective area in which home was listed.